Comments on: Bill Poser on the relation between phonology and writing http://www.garyfeng.com/wordpress/2005/07/02/bill-poser-on-the-relation-between-phonology-and-writing/ 如 影 随 行 Fri, 21 Nov 2008 12:49:24 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=1.5.1.2 by: Suzanne McCarthy http://www.garyfeng.com/wordpress/2005/07/02/bill-poser-on-the-relation-between-phonology-and-writing/#comment-965 Thu, 07 Jul 2005 20:22:22 +0000 http://www.garyfeng.com/wordpress/2005/07/02/bill-poser-on-the-relation-between-phonology-and-writing/#comment-965 I was just told that Poser's presentation at Harvard has not been published. I was just told that Poser’s presentation at Harvard has not been published.

]]> by: Suzanne McCarthy http://www.garyfeng.com/wordpress/2005/07/02/bill-poser-on-the-relation-between-phonology-and-writing/#comment-960 Wed, 06 Jul 2005 05:09:16 +0000 http://www.garyfeng.com/wordpress/2005/07/02/bill-poser-on-the-relation-between-phonology-and-writing/#comment-960 I have some major doubts about moraic orthography as well. I have less hesitiation in accepting that children access smaller and smaller phonological eegments (Sproat). However, I would like to hear what you think in contrast. I have just finished up a round of phonemic awareness testing wtiih some kindergarten students. Most children segmented bat as ba-a-t when dividing into 3 distincts sounds was modeled - none said buh-a-t. BTW Rogers hasa labeled Cree, Cherokee, Mayan and Vai as Moraic because they have CV-C units or because a symbol represents a mora. This is throwing me for a loop. The final consonants in Cree were not morae the last time I looked. Help! http://www.chass.utoronto.ca/~rogers/handouts/10Maya.pdf Suzanne I have some major doubts about moraic orthography as well. I have less hesitiation in accepting that children access smaller and smaller phonological eegments (Sproat). However, I would like to hear what you think in contrast. I have just finished up a round of phonemic awareness testing wtiih some kindergarten students. Most children segmented bat as ba-a-t when dividing into 3 distincts sounds was modeled - none said buh-a-t.

BTW Rogers hasa labeled Cree, Cherokee, Mayan and Vai as Moraic because they have CV-C units or because a symbol represents a mora. This is throwing me for a loop. The final consonants in Cree were not morae the last time I looked. Help!

http://www.chass.utoronto.ca/~rogers/handouts/10Maya.pdf

Suzanne

]]>